Splitting Jerusalem: A Team Effort
With Ehud Olmert and company committed to offering the split of Jerusalem, all sorts of political campaigns are likely to spring forth. Rallies, demonstrations, letter-writing and petitions will consume our wheel-spinning energy.
I, too, fear that we will soon find access to the Kotel and מקומות הקדושים (holy places) greatly restricted.
I, too, feel betrayed by politicians whose promises are clearly worthless.
I, too, am afraid of what international governance will mean; these international bodies can’t tie their own shoelaces, how will they govern a neighborhood as hot as that?
But I can’t get up the energy for political campaigns: they don’t work. Olmert isn’t listening, and his buddies aren’t listening. There are groups out there with greater weight than ours.
At the same time, I come back to what is, for me, the real question: Who Split Jerusalem?
Yeshayah (end of chapter 1) told us the secret to Jerusalem: ציון במשפט תפדה ושביה בצדקה – Zion will be redeemed with justice, and its returnees with righteousness. (Feel free to quibble about the precise translation and its nuances if you like.)
So I’d like to see a תכנית משפט וצדקה, a Justice and Righteousness Campaign. Not fasts and extra tehillim (although those are nice too), but Derech Eretz, proper human interaction. Looking at some Jameel and Treppenwitz messages from the past few days, and the Derech Eretz Campaign, I am especially energized for this.
- No cutting in line or in traffic, or taking advantage of easy targets
- Selflessness in all matters, an approach of “How can I help you?” even when “you” is not a customer
- Taking care of the גר, יתום ואלמנה – all of society’s vulnerable people.
I feel absurdly self-righteous making these suggestions, both because I do not excel in these areas and because they are so patently, simplistically obvious – but I have yet to see any such Campaign advertised, so I’m doing it here.
I hate to be negative, but: If we can’t do this, if we can’t adhere to Yeshayah’s demand, then we are the ones who are splitting the city, and it’s not fair to ask Olmert to be frummer than we are. If we are willing to split it in order to get an advantage for ourselves, then how can we expect Olmert not to split it in order to get an advantage for himself?
If we believe in Jerusalem-
If we believe in the Beis haMikdash-
If we believe in למען ציון לא אחשה, that we will not be silent for the sake of Zion-
Then we must also believe in Yeshayah’s prescription for the health of Jerusalem.
May we merit to see Yeshayah’s day of יקרא לך עיר הצדק, קריה נאמנה, the day when Jerusalem is again recognized as one, undivided, City of Righteousness.


6 comments:
Suggestion:
- Come up with a concrete list of behaviors, at least some of them related to blogging.
- Create an ad button, similar to the "Responsible Speech" one, and ask people to display it and link it back to your list.
- If you need help with designing your button, it seems that Jameel has some friends in the graphic design industry.
It is a good post, but I think that without political pressure we face a losing fight.
So does that mean "Zion will be redeemed with justice, and its returnees with SELF-righteousness"? ;-}
But seriously - all good ideas. Sensible things. Clearly inimical to any political process. Especially an Israeli one.
Maybe if it were more along the lines of, "blow smoke in others' faces only once per day."
"If we believe in Jerusalem-
If we believe in the Beis haMikdash-
If we believe in למען ציון לא אחשה, that we will not be silent for the sake of Zion-"
then move to Israel!!! (and bring all of your WACers with you as well). "It's returnees with righteousness" - Stand behind your words and become one of the returnees.
Hi RWAC - Loved the post.
Will think about it and get back to you, to see if we can come up with a Responsible Behavior MEME.
Isaac, Jameel-
I don't see it catching on... but if you want to do something with it, feel free. And a link is always nice.
Jack -
Agreed; we need both.
Yaakov-
Tried. The shuls there want rabbis who have lived in Israel for a while. Frankly, if I were living there I would want that, too.
Post a Comment